The study was not an introduction to a newfound study, but the literature review did not support the need for this particular study—instead demonstrating that no gap existed in the literature. The article provided information about hypothesis testing, but a confidence interval was not stated which supports the use of no parameter estimation. Critiquing a research article helps nurse judge the creditability of the information presented. The type of research design is a randomized clinical trial and is clearly stated in this report. These tools have been validated to ensure that studies can be assessed in a consistent way assessing the trustworthiness of the research article Aveyard, 2014 Qualitative research can often be labelled as biased and anecdotal however Anderson 2010 argues that when carried out rigorously it can be unbiased, in-depth… 990 Words 4 Pages form new types of interventions in order to give adequate care across a of number of fields within the system. The title appropriately indicates the target population sampled which are sedentary pregnant women, as well as the key dependent variable hypothesized to be favorably affected by the intervention which is walking or stretching exercise program. Nursing Research is the official journal of the Eastern Nursing Research Society and the Western Institute of Nursing.
Critical evaluation is defined as a systematic way of considering the truthfulness of a piece of research, the results and how relevant and applicable they are. Publication bias can occur when editors only accept manuscripts that have a bearing on the direction of their own research, or reject manuscripts with negative findings. The Book of Daniel is Scripture, not a research article. Qualitative research is a systematic, subjective approach used to describe life experiences and give them meaning Munhall, 2001. This could suggest an understanding of research giving the reader faith in their capabilities. Tables had appropriate headings and summarized large amounts of statistical data, but a legend was not provided to enable the reader to understand the statistical symbols significance to the study results. TitleThe framework suggests the title should be concise, informative, clearly specify the content and indicate the research approach.
Educational levels of hospital nurses and surgical patient mortality. The nature of the sport could also be critical. History and evolution of nursing theory 7. It is imperative in nursing that care has its foundations in sound research, and it is essential that all nurses have the ability to critically appraise research to identify what is best practice. In conclusion I will express my own view point of why theory has been neglected.
The framework presented in this article addresses both quantitative and qualitative research within one list of questions. Since the sample selection method is unclear, it may have been inappropriate, denoting further flaws which affect the remainder of the paper. Well-designed reviews characterizing symptomphenotypes are also encouraged. It is better to have it to support the findings. There were significant differences between the three levels.
However the reader performed an online search and found the authors have had previous papers published suggesting research experience, which gives confidence in their abilities. The article has given a summary within 150 words. This paper would have been even better if the student had added a sentence or two about the results of the study. The review concludes lengthy summary of relevant literature and its implications for the research problem under study. Hypothesis The researcher does not state the hypothesis in this study. Performing your own critical analysis of an article allows you to consider its value to you and to your workplace.
These findings offer insights into the potential benefits of a more highly educated nurse workforce. Her model was originally developed, not to be a nursing theory, but to attempt to teach nursing students a new approach to daily nursing activities. Executive summary: Final report of the Task Force on the North Carolina Nursing Workforce. Nursing research: principles, process and issues. Nursing Research is a peer reviewed , double-blind journal.
Final Thoughts Undertaking a critique of a research article may seem challenging at first, but will help you to evaluate whether the article has relevance to your own practice and workplace. Only Qualified Specialists Article Critique Example One of the ways of simplifying the whole process of completing the assignment is using an article critique example. Implications included practical and effective ways to implement their study findings. References These should be relevant to the study, be up to date, and should provide a comprehensive list of citations within the text. The abstract is well structured per the journal principles and is complete in presenting the key points of each section of the article. The Theory of Need was developed by Virginia Henderson and was derived from her education and nursing practice.
However the table appears complex, confusing and impossible to understand; therefore the reader would question the internal consistency. Burns and Grove 2003 states this helps to influence the reader to read the remainder of the report. Research and theory exploded among the nursing profession through case studies American Nurses Association, 2010. In essence, a nursing theory enables understanding of what, how, and why nurses continue to practice. The researcher explains why the research is important and was logically organized. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise.
The authors analyzed outcomes data derived from hospital discharge abstracts that were merged with information on the characteristics of the treating hospitals, including unique data obtained from surveys of hospital nurses. Measurement, statistics, informatics and analytics, qualitative, and mixed methods approaches. Therefore the reader believes this paper does not establish contamination from case notes, so is unreliable and lacks validity. Research Problem and Purpose Logically placed, the research problem is clearly and concisely stated within the first paragraph of the article. While frameworks for critiquing qualitative research exist, they are often complex and more suited to the needs of students engaged in advanced levels of study. The title however would be clearer if the authors reflected target population, as readers would be easier identifying the subjects involved in their study. This suggests the researches appear to have only reported the finding of other studies and not examined the material, which, Peat 2001 states is essential for making decisions about whether or not to change practice on the basis of published report.